Skip to main content
BlogCulinary Collections

Ultimate Nut Butter Guide

If you’re on Instagram (Nutiva is, come say “hi!”) and you type in anything related to nut butters, you’ll find thousands and thousands of posts. Take for example #NutButter or #NutButters. And that’s just the beginning of where the nut butter conversations begin. Personally, I am a fan of many brands for all the delicious and organic nut butters they have brought to the marketplace. But as the past owner of a nut butter company, A Loving Spoon nut butters, I know that you can just as easily make your own. With that, today I’m giving you my Ultimate Nut Butter Guide.
Below is a list of all the nut butter recipes I have created and published for anyone to consume.
Click HERE to save these for later.
Ultimate Nut Butter Guide 4 DIY organic nut butter recipes

Additionally, there are 4 recipes (Honey Vanilla Bourbon Peanut Butter, Salted Cinnamon Almond Butter, Java Almond Chip, and Samarah’s Cinny-Vanilly Peanut Cashew Butter) that I have never released publicly (and never will release publicly) because they are found via an exclusive A Loving Spoon nut butters recipe e-book.
I began the nut butter business in my home kitchen, but once the product became popular, I moved into a Commercial Kitchen, where I was able to make a larger quantity. From all the years in the home kitchen and Commercial Kitchen (and working with food scientists), I learned a lot about how to make an amazing nut butter.
I am asked all the time, “What is the secret to a great nut butter?”
MCT Carrot Cake Walnut Butter Nutiva Organic MCT Oil ingredients nut butter
“Hands down,” I’ll say, “the ingredients you use to make up that nut butter.” I learned very quickly that an ingredient can make or break a recipe, and I learned this through the vanilla extract sourced. Not all vanilla is created equally. Not all ingredients, on the whole, are created equally. You must choose wisely.
Beyond that, for me, it became a simple formula, and I’ll share it with you today in this Ultimate Nut Butter Guide.

Ultimate Nut Butter Guide

Click HERE to save the Ultimate Nut Butter Guide for later.
Ultimate Nut Butter Guide

Prep Steps

  1. Choose your base, aka the nut you will use.
  2. Decide if you want just a plain nut butter or one that’s more dessert in nature (this guide assumes you’ll want something more dessert than plain). If you want just a plain nut butter, then you simply need to choose nut, salt or no salt, and added oil or no oil.
  3. Choose either salt or no salt.
  4. Figure out if you want to add an oil or no oil.
  5. Pick a sweetener, if desired.
  6. Decide if you want to add a nutritional boost.
  7. Determine whether or not you want additional dessert-like ingredients added.

Nut Options

MCT Cashew Almond Nut Butter Blending Organic Nuts
Use unsalted nuts, and add salt in, to taste. Using salted nuts will produce an overly salted batch of nut butter that you are not likely to enjoy.

  • peanuts
  • almonds
  • walnuts
  • cashews
  • brazil
  • pecans
  • sunflower
  • hazelnut
  • macadamia
  • pistachio
  • sesame

Salt Options

  • Sea salt
  • Himalayan salt
  • Fleur de sel

Oil Options

MCT Pumpkin Spiced Latte Nutiva Organic MCT Oil

Sweetener Options

Pumpkin Spiced Whipped Cream Nutiva Organic Coconut Manna Coconut Sugar

Nutritional Boost Options

7 Heart Healthy Seeds Chia Seeds Nutiva organic

Additional Dessert-Like Ingredient Options

  • raisins
  • cranberries
  • cacao nibs/chocolate chips
  • extracts (vanilla, coffee, peppermint, etc.)
  • coconut flakes
  • other dried fruit (apples, bananas, etc.)

How to Determine Quantities

For at-home, small batch quantity, the way to keep it as fresh as possible is to make them in 8oz jars.
To produce an 8oz jar of nut butter, you’ll need approximately 2 cups of chosen nuts and any other options you want added in.
For 2 cups of nuts, I would use 1/2 tsp of salt to start with. Remember, you can always add more, but you can’t subtract.
If you choose to use an oil, for 2 cups of nuts, I would start with 1-2 Tbsp oil.
If you add in a sweetener, start with 1/2 – 1 Tbsp sweetener (except not that much for monk fruit).
For the nutritional boost and additional dessert-like ingredients, start with 1 Tbsp for things like the chia seeds, hempseed, raisins, cranberries, cacao nibs, coconut flakes, and other dried fruit. Start with 1 tsp for things like cinnamon, cacao powder, and extracts. Stick to 1/2 tsp or less of things like ginger and nutmeg.

How to Make the Nut Butter

Purely Cacao Peanut Butter PB

  1. Place nuts and oil in a food processor. Blend until creamy.
  2. Add the rest of the ingredients, except the salt and any larger dessert-like ingredients like cacao nibs, raisins, etc. and blend until completely mixed together.
  3. Finally, toss in the salt and dessert-like ingredients, and blend for about 10 seconds until blended.
  4. Remove finished product, and place in a glass jar.

And that’s it. Most nut butters can be stored in the cupboard, but you can place them in the fridge if desired as well.
What is your favorite kind of nut butter?

Made With Nutiva

Organic Coconut Sugar
Organic Coconut Sugar

With a subtly sweet taste, unrefined and unprocessed Nutiva Organic Coconut Sugar is the smarter sweetener option

Shop Now
Organic MCT Oil
Organic MCT Oil

We extract medium-chain triglycerides (MCTs) from virgin coconut oil, so you can enjoy a convenient Certified Organic energy boost

Shop Now
Organic Virgin Coconut Oil
Organic Virgin Coconut Oil

Cold-pressed and never refined, rich in lauric acid and versatile in your kitchen

Shop Now
Related Recipes You might be interested in...


Add a Comment


  1. Nechama says:

    I lightly roast the nuts before processing, but sometimes it comes out not quite smooth enough. One recipe said to soak the nuts first. But that didn’t seem to help make the butter. What could I do to make it more smooth, beside adding honey or coconut oil.

  2. Kim Smyth says:

    I have tried every nut butter on the market since going Paleo and avoiding peanuts, and I have to say my favorite so far is Cashew butter, although I have never tried to make it myself. I did make cashew based Ice cream which called for soaking the cashews first. You don’t have to soak them prior to making cashew butter?

    1. Nutiva Team Nutiva says:

      Hi Kim,
      Our recipe does not require soaking the cashews before processing.

  3. Corn News says:

    Your enrollment extremely cool. I alert to be here. I enjoyed drill your articles and i would savor to bookmark your posts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Newsletter Get the Scoop